New front stairs with or without railings and a gate?

by brae Email

I have two possible entryway designs to choose from, and I'd love your opinions.  Click images to enlarge.

I didn't mind the original front steps of the Heritage kit, but once I found this inspiration photo they didn't stand a chance.  I love these stone steps!


I found an excellent tutorial by Lesley Shepherd online while searching for additional stone stair images in which foam core board and air dry clay were used to mimic stone stairs.

I bought some 1/2" thick foam core board and cut some new stairs for the entry.  I didn't cut sides, but I did put the horses from Katie on some pedestals at the end (a bit too tall on the part of the pedestals, but you get the idea).

The stairs and pedestals get somewhat lost in the overall look, but I think that's just because they aren't painted and the porch isn't on, etc.

The second option involves wrought iron railings and gate posts with the horses on either side of the gate.  I'm not sold on these railings in particular, but I happened to have a sample in my miniatures stash.

I am limiting my front yard to just about where the railings are (a board size of 25" deep) so I can move this house around my real life house, in and out of doorways.  So, I can shorten the depth of the front steps or have this maximum amount of yard from the gate to the steps.

So, what do you think?  With or without the railing?  :D

----------------

Here are a few more photos with Lyssa's suggestion of painting the stairs for a better mockup.  Borrowed some random Newport parts for the porch, too.  Now I am even more undecided!  :O

--------------

Okay, I think I've got it.  I angled the stairs, added sides and small pedestals, and put it with the gate posts.  :D  Hurray!

Note: I couldn't find any artist info on the creepy house photo, so if this is your photo and you'd like it removed, please contact me.

10 comments

Comment from: Lyssa [Visitor]
I have helped on Greenleaf, but now with some more looking, I am torn. I like both looks. :D

LOVE the steps though.

08/03/11 @ 18:33
Comment from: Cecelia [Visitor]
Hi Brae. Love what you have done so far. I kind of like having railings around the house. It gives it more of a "keep out" feeling vs "abandoned". maybe you could make or find some kind of "creep" looking railing. just my opinion though.
08/03/11 @ 19:23
Comment from: Lucille [Visitor]
Brae, I prefer with the railings. They contribute atmosphere and drama in keeping with the haunted house look you're aiming for. I love your stairs!
08/03/11 @ 19:32
Comment from: brae [Member] Email
Thank you! The ideas are definitely a-churnin'. :>> Not to worry, Cecelia...that pretty railing isn't staying.
08/03/11 @ 19:32
Comment from: Mona [Visitor]
You came up with a great solution when it comes to the stairs. Your house will be amazing.
08/04/11 @ 00:02
Comment from: Keli [Visitor]
That is a very hard decision.

At first I thought the fence was too much of a focal point, but then I realized it's the first thing my eyes land on, then they converge on the steps and travel up to the front door, then the rest of the house. I like that.
08/04/11 @ 03:53
Comment from: Tabitha Corsica [Visitor]
I do like the look in the last photo but I agree the railings need to be more derelict... The stone stairs will be great!
08/04/11 @ 04:38
Comment from: Deb Kelly [Visitor]
Much creepier with the railings. Great focal point because it draws the eyes up the stairs to the rest of the house. I'm already scared!
08/04/11 @ 10:25
Comment from: katie [Visitor]
Now I like the railings:) And I love the last photo... Maybe at one time, it had been beautiful, but through the years it has been neglected...and is now covered in rust and mossy stuff?

And I LOVE LOVE what you did with the horse heads! How smart!!
08/04/11 @ 18:17
Comment from: Sandra from Sydney [Visitor] Email
I like the railings too, it gives a boundary to the project and draws your eyes through to the stairs. I like the railings design, and once you make it more decrepit it would be fine, but whatever design you use I think gives a nicer finish to the whole house.
08/08/11 @ 19:41